Abelard and Heloise

Constant J. Mews offers an intellectual biography of two of the best known personalities of the twelfth century. Peter Abelard was a controversial logician at the cathedral school of Notre-Dame in Paris when he first met Heloise who was the brilliant and outspoken niece of a cathedral canon and who was then engaged in the study of philosophy. After an intense love affair and the birth of a child they married in secret in a bid to placate her uncle. Nonetheless the vengeful canon Fulbert had Abelard castrated following which he became a monk at St. Denis while Heloise became a nun at Argenteuil. Mews a recognized authority on Abelard''s writings traces his evolution as a thinker from his earliest work on dialectic (paying particular attention to his debt to Roscelin of Compiègne and William of Champeaux) to his most mature reflections on theology and ethics. Abelard''s interest in the doctrine of universals was one part of his broader philosophical interest in language theology and ethics says Mews. He argues that Heloise played a significant role in broadening Abelard''s intellectual interests during the period 1115-17 as reflected in a passionate correspondence in which the pair articulated and debated the nature of their love. Mews believes that the sudden end of this early relationship provoked Abelard to return to writing about language with new depth and to begin applying these concerns to theology. Only after Abelard and Heloise resumed close epistolary contact in the early 1130s however did Abelard start to develop his thinking about sin and redemption--in ways that respond closely to the concerns of Heloise. Mews emphasizes both continuity and development in what these two very original thinkers had to say.