Bioethics and Secular Humanism

Bioethics is vitally important in our day because it represents the critical expression of interest in the proper use of medical science to provide health care. Secular humanism is important because it is a central factor in constructing a common morality that does not make special appeal to such things as religious assumptions. The argument of this book therefore will be of profound interest to all who are concerned for the well-being of humanity in todays world. Imagine the author says Roman Catholics and committed atheists disputing over proper abortion policies. Imagine individuals who wish to organize a for-profit surrogate mother service confronting individuals who view such endeavors as exploitation of women. To what moral premise do they appeal? Are power and influence the deciding factors or is it possible to establish certain principles to which all may appeal? In answer Professor Engelhardt examines the various meanings of secularity and humanism clearly showing how complex they are. Alongside this he demonstrates the diversity of bioethics and the problems of laying a foundation for it. Based on these considerations he identifies which ways forward are the most promising. The urgency of the task is clear. New biomedical possibilities are surfacing at the very time that demands to contain health care costs pose difficult ethical problems. Englehardt at his best--and thats outstanding. In the current debate about the role of religion and reason in bioethics Engelhadts examination of the possibilities and limitations of secular humanism in bioethics is important. While stressing the limitations of secular humanism as a content-full position he defends it as a content-less perspective for peaceable negotiation among moral strangers. His central thesis is compelling and he argues for it in a provocative imaginative and rigorous way. This profound book deserves a wide audience and I recommend it with great enthusiasm. -James F. Childress Professor of Religious Studies in the University of Virginia A constructive account of secular humanism as a necessary morality for maintaining social cooperation between moral strangers. Engelhardt presents philosophically sophisticated and historically informed arguments to support his view that secular humanism need be neither antireligious and/or presuppose foundational accounts of rationality. Many will find his position outrageous but there can be no doubt that it must be taken seriously by all religious and secular thinkers who would confront our violent world. -Stanley Hauerwas Professor of Theological Ethics at Duke University North Carolina What may be the fundamental work in bioethics for our time. Instead of despairing over the moral fragmentation of the postmodern condition Engelhardt argues persuasively for a common faith in the efficacy of a shared human rationality which he characterizes as secular humanism giving his concept a surprising new reading. The book is essential reading not only for philosophers theologians physicians and other health care providers and policy makers but for all of us who are concerned with the human response to human suffering illness and need. -Marx W. Wartofsky Distinguished Professor of Philosophy at the City University of New York H. Tristram Engelhardt Jr. is Professor in the Department of Philosophy Rice University and Professor Emeritus Departments of Medicine and Community Medicine Baylor College of Medicine Houston Texas.