Hans Kelsen's Normativism

Hans Kelsen''s Pure Theory of Law is the most prominent example of legal normativism. This text traces its origins and its genesis. In philosophy normativism started with Hume''s distinction between Is- and Ought-propositions. Kant distinguished practical from theoretical judgments while resting even the latter on normativity. Following him Lotze and the Baden neo-Kantians instrumentalized normativism to secure a sphere of knowledge which is not subject to the natural sciences. Even in his first major text Kelsen claims that law is solely a matter of Ought or normativity. In the second phase of his writings he places himself into the neo-Kantian tradition holding legal norms to be Ought-judgments of legal science. In the third phase he advocates a barely coherent naive normative realism. In the fourth phase he supplements the realist view with a strict will-theory of norms coupled with set-pieces from linguistic philosophy; classical normativism is more or less dismantled.