Monastic Prisons and Torture Chambers: Crime and Punishment in Central European Monasteries 1600-1800

Following the Council of Trent (1545-1563) Catholic religious orders underwent substantial reform. Nevertheless on occasion monks and nuns had to be disciplined and--if they had committed a crime--punished. Consequently many religious orders relied on sophisticated criminal law traditions that included torture physical punishment and prison sentences. Ulrich L. Lehner provides for the first time an overview of how monasteries in central Europe prosecuted crime and punished their members and thus introduces a host of new questions for anyone interested in state-church relations gender questions the history of violence or the development of modern monasticism. Lehners brave ambitious and learned study uncovers the little-known history of secret monastic prisons for wayward monks and nuns and the clandestine use of torture in monastic legal proceedings. . . . This is church history at its best. It deserves to be widely known and imitated. --H. C. Erik Midelfort University of Virginia In this path-breaking lucid book Ulrich Lehner challenges conventional wisdom on the nature and purpose of prisons and punishment in early modern central Europe. Exploiting neglected evidence on monastic prisons and trial procedures he demonstrates that the Mendicant orders continued medieval standards as the post-Tridentine religious adopted milder discipline. . . . A book of major significance it will spur further research into our understanding of confinement and punishment. --Gregg Roeber Pennsylvania State University Ulrich Lehner who has become a master of all things Catholic in eighteenth-century Europe here examines the sorry record of crime and punishment within selected European monasteries. His conclusion is persuasive--that moral failings of these institutions should not overwhelm other evidence of improved moral standards in the Tridentine Church. All who look for a fuller account of official Catholicism in the era whipsawed by both the Enlightenment and rising governmental absolutism will thank him for the careful research underlying this book. --Mark A. Noll University of Notre Dame Ulrich L. Lehner is Associate Professor of Historical Theology and Religious History at Marquette University. He is the author or editor of over a dozen books on early modern religion including Enlightened Monks (2011) and the main organizer of The Oxford Handbook of Early Modern Theology (forthcoming).