Neither Necessary nor Inevitable: "History Needn't Have Been Like That"

Historic determinism is a convenient way to tie up the uncomfortable loose ends in the tragic lives of millions and to explain at the same time the exceptional opportunities of many of the rest of us. A belief in an inevitable chain of events or the will of God or destiny or historic necessity suggests a formula to justify each situation as inevitable. Here history is seen like a single track on which people ride in different cultural coaches in the same direction. Every stop every departure is part of a natural schedule. It readily leads to resignation for many and arrogance for the lucky. Neither Necessary nor Inevitable argues and illustrates that such attention to the sirens of retrospective determinism gives a false sense of security and a freedom from responsibility. When history swallows the importance of peoples choices inalienable rights become inalienable conditions. In Neither Necessary nor Inevitable Udo Middelmann argues that while written history may tell a story of choices and consequences in a tight mesh living history is the result of genuine choices that render the record too chaotic to support the belief in a controlling master plan of material or divine intention. Instead we each lay down our cultural tracks with personally significant choices. Turns and stops are not inevitable and each choice affects the course of history for generations. Responsibility is not reduced by the belief in a necessary history or a willful God. Udo Middelmann presents an impressive and refreshing case for a view of human history that preserves the wonder of man as a true moral agent while affirming a biblical understanding of God as the providential One who works in time. This brilliant treatment deals with a difficult and often misunderstood subject of the relationship between mans choices and Gods plan. Middelmann distinguishes himself by offering a compelling argument grounded in the notion of form and freedom that strikes a proper balance between Gods purposes and mans freedom. He argues persuasively that mans free choices actually contribute to the shape of human history but always within the form of Gods overall plan. Appreciatively Middelmann does this while avoiding any notion of open theism. His intellectually rigorous treatment within this book makes history more than a piece of theater and yet avoids placing man in a chaotic world. The Christian community owes a great debt to Middelmann for his precision in thought and well-informed mind that has crafted this most important work. -Bruce A. Little Professor of Philosophy Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary Finally a much needed intellectual tonic to help us decipher the strains of ancient Hellenic and religious pluralism that cloud the moral framework of historic Judaic-Christianity. With numerous examples from history and key texts Udo Middelmann unpacks the loss of historical engagement and moral will in much theological thinking aiming to recover the agency and dignity of the believer and the infinite-personal God for our times. Provocative and highly recommended. -Mike T. Sugimoto Professor of Asian Studies Pepperdine University Finally someone skillfully challenges the widely held assumption that everything happens for a reason as if guided by an unseen hand. Years of work in the former Soviet Union demonstrate the sad reality of what a fatalistic mindset can do to a people and a nation. The events of life are assumed to be both necessary and inevitable with disastrous consequences both personally and nationally. Udo Middlemann provides insight and thoughtful consideration to the reality that our choices not only matter but are indeed history making. -Jesse L. James Founder and CEO Global Leadership Inc. Udo Midddelmann is that rare Christian intellectual who thinks otherwise; writing against current ideological and political determinisms as well as the easy certitudes of a compromised Christianity he subjec