Ramanuja and Schleiermacher: Toward a Constructive Comparative Theology: 159 (Princeton Theological Monograph)

Synopsis: Can the comparison of two theologians vastly separated in space and time help contemporary theologians to think better? This book argues that it can. Specifically this book argues that the novel and burgeoning discipline of comparative theology is a powerful method for gaining critical insight into our inherited worldviews. More important it argues that the critical insights gained through comparison can produce constructive theology or in other words revised and renewed worldviews. New comparisons produce new questions and new questions produce new answers. In order to demonstrate the power of this process the book compares two preeminent theologians Sri Ramanuja of the Hindu tradition and Friedrich Schleiermacher of the Christian tradition. Each argues that God sustains the universe at every moment of its existence but they work out the divine sustenance in very different ways. By comparing their description of Gods continual preservation of the universe this book asks original unfamiliar questions of each. Then it speculatively suggests possible answers to those questions inviting Ramanuja and Schleiermacher to respond to the challenges raised. This method demonstrates the incisive power of comparative theology to generate critical tension as well as the creative power of comparative theology to resolve that very tension. Endorsements: This is a fine example of comparative theology in action. If readers want to know how the discipline works when it works well they can turn to Ramanuja and Schleiermacher. -Francis X. Clooney Director of the Center for the Study of World Religions Harvard Divinity School Across time and cultures great figures within a single religious tradition become part of an ongoing scholarly interaction and argument. Only recently has this intimacy of conversation been extended across religious boundaries themselves. Sydnor offers us a theological dialogue between two giants the Vaisnavite thinker Ramanuja and the Protestant theologian Schleiermacher. Sensitive to the distinctive settings of each he is able to draw them into a fruitful collaboration around the questions of human and cosmic dependence on the divine. This is a constructive comparative theology that focuses the reader on the substance of these writers rather than the mechanics of interreligious study. Sydnors book will be of interest both to those who value the depth of research behind the comparison and to those who are simply looking for theological light on the experience of absolute dependence. --S. Mark Heim Samuel Abbot Professor of Christian Theology Andover Newton Theological School In this acutely reasoned stirring and accessible analysis a blossoming philosopher-theologian-pastor-educator Jon Paul Sydnor brings forth accurate in-depth readings of primary works by Schleiermacher and Ramanuja. Using up-to-date procedures his comparison of these two highly discerning seminal thinkers enables a still wider conversation between Christians and Hindus today. Here newly honed questions observations and insights vie with each other for attention. Overall Sydnors work calls forth a pondering over meanings and prospects that only this emergent field of comparative theology can offer. Within this new movement it will bear the reputation of a pioneering work. --Terrence N. Tice Professor Emeritus of Philosophy University of Michigan Author Biography: Jon Paul Sydnor has studied at the University of Virginia Princeton Theological Seminary and Boston College. He currently teaches world religions at Emmanuel College in Boston.