The Vetting of Wisdom: Joan Montgomery and the fight for PLC

In the story of the biggest school blow-up in Australian history The Vetting of Wisdom is a gripping tale of a revered Principal-acclaimed nationwide as the leading girls school educator of her day-loved and admired by all-but with a determined Presbyterian Church minority bent on getting rid of her. Following the formation of the Uniting Church in 1977 the continuing Presbyterians seized PLC and Scotch College from what they saw as the wreckage of Church Union and sought to cast the premier girls school in their own church-focused image. They were met by court cases parliamentary fiats outraged parents storms of mail fiery Council debates packed public meetings and a voluminous disbelieving press. But after years of bitter protest Joan Montgomery eventually fell only to be replaced by PLCs first male headmaster in 47 years. For Kim Rubenstein a former PLC school captain and now with her own brilliant career it was her first experience of power trumping reason. In the busy years since school she has often puzzled over what made Montgomery such an inspiring role model for PLC girls and what in the end made Joans detractors think otherwise. The Vetting of Wisdom: Joan Montgomery and the Fight for PLC is the careful piecing together of this puzzle.